Compare: NH-D15 G2 vs Mugen 6

Displayed below are comprehensive data and graphs that compare the Noctua NH-D15 G2 to the Scythe Mugen 6, showcasing critical qualitative and performance metrics. Performance metrics are further segmented into distinct graphs while leveraging the AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D, illustrating how each cooler performs under various varying CPU power levels. This allows for a clear comparison of their relative performance and sound output when under different heat loads. The comparison is conducted under the following conditions:
  • Case: Praxis Wetbench
  • Ambient Temperatures: 23°C
  • CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D (Pick Another CPU)

CPU Cooler Details

Metric Cooler 1: NH-D15 G2 Cooler 2: Mugen 6
Cooler Name NH-D15 G2 Mugen 6
Fan 1 Name NF-A14x25r G2 Wonder Tornado 120 - WT1225FD20-P
Fan 2 Name NF-A14x25r G2
Manufacture Rated dBa 24.8 26.88
Number of Heat Pipes 8 6
Full Size (WxHxD): 150x168x152 mm 132x154x106 mm
Heatsink 1 (WxHxD) 150x120x55 mm 129x110x80 mm
Heatsink 2 (WxHxD) 150x120x50 mm
Air Cooler Rating: Install 7 (Easy) 7 (Easy)
Manufacture's Link NH-D15 G2 Manufacture's Link Mugen 6 Manufacture's Link

Product Links

Link Type Cooler 1: NH-D15 G2 Cooler 2: Mugen 6
Amazon.com

Fan Details for CPU Cooler:


Fan 1

Metric Cooler 1 Cooler 2
Fan Name NF-A14x25r G2 Wonder Tornado 120 - WT1225FD20-P
Fan Location Front Front
Fan Flow Type Push Push
CPU Only Fan No No
Max RPM 1500 2000
Fan Size (mm) 140 120
Fan Width (mm) 25 26
Manufacture Rated dBa 24.8 35.6
Manufactured Rated Airflow (cmf) 91.6 75.2
Manufactured Rated Air Pressure (h2o) 3.4
Number Of Pins 4 4
PWM Fan Yes Yes
Bearing Type SSO2 Fluid Dynamic
Watts (W) 2.28 1.80
Current (A) 0.19 0.15
Max Volts 12.00 12.00

Fan 2

Metric Cooler 1 Cooler 2
Fan Name NF-A14x25r G2
Fan Location Mid
Fan Flow Type Mid
CPU Only Fan No
Max RPM 1500
Fan Size (mm) 140
Fan Width (mm) 25
Manufacture Rated dBa 24.8
Manufactured Rated Airflow (cmf) 91.6
Manufactured Rated Air Pressure (h2o)
Number Of Pins 4
PWM Fan Yes
Bearing Type SSO2
Watts (W) 2.28
Current (A) 0.19
Max Volts 12.00


Design and Aesthetics:


NH-D15 G2

This cooler is quite large and showcases Noctua's signature design, appealing to diehard PC builders who don't want to compromise on cooling performance. The NH-D15 G2 closely resembles the previous generation, with a few updates. This version features eight heat pipes and offset depths on the two heatsinks

Mugen 6

This cooler features a sleek, monolithic design with an exposed metal heatsink and a polished top that conceals the heat-pipe ends, giving it a clean, refined appearance. It comes with a single 120mm black fan, with the option to add a second for enhanced cooling performance. While other design variations exist, this model emphasizes simplicity and modern aesthetics.


Install Notes:


NH-D15 G2

The NH-D15 G2 retains the same installation design as its predecessor, with the addition of a new bracket that allows for offset mounting on AM5 CPUs. The installation process is straightforward, guided by clear instructions that adhere to industry standards for top-tier coolers. However, the cooler's large size may pose challenges when maneuvering it within the case.

Mugen 6

The Scythe Mugen 6 features a standard installation process, where brackets are first attached to the motherboard, followed by the cooler. It includes a single fan, with the option to install a second for enhanced cooling performance. Its design ensures compatibility with most motherboards, without interfering with RAM placement.




Cooling Performance:


NH-D15 G2

The Noctua's NH-D15 G2 cooler is hard to beat in terms of cooling performance, even outperforming AIOs from various other brands—a result expected given its larger size. However, when compared to the previous generation, its performance is on par, offering little improvement.

Mugen 6

This cooler delivers above-average performance and its performance is in line given its size and single fan configuration. With the option to add a second fan, it allows for improved cooling and a better noise-to-performance ratio at minimal cost, offering upgrade flexibility. However, in its default configuration, it may not be sufficient for high-end CPUs that generate significant heat.


Noise Performance:


NH-D15 G2

Compared to the average cooler, the Noctua NH-D15 G2 is louder than most on the market. However, when performance is evaluated on a noise-normalized basis, this cooler is tough to beat, offering excellent cooling for a given noise level. This means you can keep your cooler quiet when needed, while still having the headroom to increase the speed for enhanced cooling performance.

Mugen 6

This cooler boasts an excellent noise profile, thanks to its single 120mm fan. While adding a second fan can enhance overall cooling and improve the sound-to-performance ratio, it may also lead to increased noise levels at higher speeds. Overall, the cooler maintains a good balance between noise and performance, especially considering its size and fan configuration.


Summary:


NH-D15 G2

The Noctua NH-D15 G2 retains the familiar installation design of its predecessor, with the addition of a new bracket for offset mounting on AM5 CPUs. While its large size may make installation a bit challenging, the process is straightforward, with clear instructions that meet industry standards. The cooler's substantial size is matched by its performance, offering exceptional cooling that even surpasses many AIOs from other brands. Although its performance is on par with the previous generation, the NH-D15 G2 still delivers excellent cooling, particularly when considering noise levels. Despite being louder than the average cooler, it excels in noise-normalized performance, allowing users to maintain quiet operation while having the flexibility to ramp up speed for maximum cooling when needed.

Mugen 6

The Scythe Mugen 6 features a straightforward installation process, with brackets attached to the motherboard before securing the cooler. Its monolithic design includes an exposed metal heatsink and polished top, hiding the heat-pipe ends for a clean, modern look. It comes with a single 120mm black fan, with the option to add a second for enhanced cooling performance. The cooler is compatible with most motherboards, avoiding interference with RAM placement. Offering above-average performance, the option for a second fan allows for improved cooling and a better noise-to-performance ratio, though overall noise levels may increase at higher speeds. In its default configuration, the cooler performs well but may not be sufficient for high-end CPUs that produce significant heat. Overall, it strikes an impressive balance between noise and performance.


AMD 5800X3D CPU Box Image

AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D

Pick Another CPU

CPU Details:

Metric Value
Brand AMD
Cooler Name Ryzen 7 5800X3D
CPU Socket AM4
Cores 8
Thread Count 16
Max Temperature 90°C
Base Clock 3.4GHz
Max Boost Clock 4.5GHz
Cache L1 512KB
Cache L2 4MB
Cache L3 96MB
Processor Power Base 105W
Manufacture's Link Ryzen 7 5800X3D Manufacture's Link

Product Links

Link Type Value
Amazon.com

Loading...

Copyright © 2023 · All Rights Reserved ·
Contact: derekleetechtalks@gmail.com · Privacy Policy