Compare: NH-U12S Redux vs Frost Commander 140

Noctua NH-U12S Redux manufacture's image

Noctua NH-U12S Redux

Compare To Another Cooler
Thermalright Frost Commander 140 manufacture's image

Thermalright Frost Commander 140

Compare To Another Cooler
Displayed below are comprehensive data and graphs that compare the Noctua NH-U12S Redux to the Thermalright Frost Commander 140, showcasing critical qualitative and performance metrics. Performance metrics are further segmented into distinct graphs while leveraging the AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D, illustrating how each cooler performs under various varying CPU power levels. This allows for a clear comparison of their relative performance and sound output when under different heat loads. The comparison is conducted under the following conditions:
  • Case: Praxis Wetbench
  • Ambient Temperatures: 23°C
  • CPU: AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D (Pick Another CPU)

CPU Cooler Details

Metric Cooler 1: NH-U12S Redux Cooler 2: Frost Commander 140
Cooler Name NH-U12S Redux Frost Commander 140
Fan 1 Name NF-P12 redux-1700 PWM TL-C12 Pro-G
Fan 2 Name TL-D14X
Manufacture Rated dBa 25.1 30.2
Number of Heat Pipes 4 5
Full Size (WxHxD): 125x158x45 mm 140x158x121 mm
Heatsink 1 (WxHxD) 124x108x45 mm 143x120x46 mm
Heatsink 2 (WxHxD) 143x120x46 mm
Air Cooler Rating: Install 8 (Easy) 7 (Easy)
Manufacture's Link NH-U12S Redux Manufacture's Link Frost Commander 140 Manufacture's Link

Product Links

Link Type Cooler 1: NH-U12S Redux Cooler 2: Frost Commander 140
Amazon.com

Fan Details for CPU Cooler:


Fan 1

Metric Cooler 1 Cooler 2
Fan Name NF-P12 redux-1700 PWM TL-C12 Pro-G
Fan Location Front Front
Fan Flow Type Push Push
CPU Only Fan No No
Max RPM 1700 1850
Fan Size (mm) 120 120
Fan Width (mm) 25 25
Manufacture Rated dBa 25.1 29.6
Manufactured Rated Airflow (cmf) 70.7 82.0
Manufactured Rated Air Pressure (h2o) 2.8 2.1
Number Of Pins 4 4
PWM Fan Yes Yes
Bearing Type SSO Fluid Dynamic
Watts (W) 1.08 3.00
Current (A) 0.09 0.25
Max Volts 12.00 12.00

Fan 2

Metric Cooler 1 Cooler 2
Fan Name TL-D14X
Fan Location Mid
Fan Flow Type Mid
CPU Only Fan No
Max RPM 1800
Fan Size (mm) 140
Fan Width (mm) 27
Manufacture Rated dBa 30.2
Manufactured Rated Airflow (cmf) 95.5
Manufactured Rated Air Pressure (h2o) 2.3
Number Of Pins 4
PWM Fan Yes
Bearing Type Fluid Dynamic
Watts (W) 3.60
Current (A) 0.30
Max Volts 12.00


Design and Aesthetics:


NH-U12S Redux

The NH-U12S redux features a single-tower design with a slim aluminum heatsink and a single 120mm NF-P12 redux-1700 PWM fan. This design ensures efficient heat dissipation while maintaining compatibility with various system configurations, including those with tall RAM modules. Aesthetically, the NH-U12S redux adopts a more neutral gray color scheme, providing a sleek and modern appearance that complements various build themes.

Frost Commander 140

The Frost Commander is a sleek CPU cooler with a design reminiscent of the Peerless Assassin 120. This cooler features a dual-tower heatsink with 5 heat pipes for efficient heat dissipation, and uniquely, the heat pipe ends are hidden from view. Sporting gray and silver tones, the Thermalright logo adorns the top of the heatsink. Despite its larger radiator, the Frost Commander uses a single 120mm fan in front and a 140mm fan between the heatsinks, giving it a distinct, asymmetrical look.


Install Notes:


NH-U12S Redux

The NH-U12S Redux features Noctua's SecuFirm2 mounting system, ensuring compatibility with a wide range of Intel and AMD sockets and offering a straightforward installation process, typical of Noctua coolers. Clear instructions, high-quality components, and a tube of their premium NT-H1 thermal compound make it an easy and user-friendly experience, even for beginners. The cooler uses the original AMD backplate for AMD installations. However, one downside is that the cooler may stick to your CPU, and due to the screw setup, you can't slide the cooler off the CPU like with some other brands. Overall, the NH-U12S Redux offers a relatively hassle-free installation process.

Frost Commander 140

The cooler installation is quite similar to other mainstream cooler setups. However, during installation, securing the fans to the heatsink requires more effort (relative to other Thermalright offerings), which is due to the metal securing the fans requiring much more effort to place. For this reason, it's also a lot easier to slightly bend the heatsink fins, but this can be fixed by bending it back with a credit card.

Additionally, like other mainstream coolers, the Frost Frost Commander faces challenges in uninstalling when trying to break the thermal paste seal between the cooler and CPU, as it doesn't easily slide or twist off. This can be an issue if the thermal paste forms a strong bond.




Cooling Performance:


NH-U12S Redux

The performance of the NH-U12S redux is solid, thanks to its four heat pipes that efficiently transfer heat away from the CPU and into the large fin array of the heatsink. It is suitable for a wide range of processors, from mainstream to some high-end models. While it may not offer the same level of cooling performance as the original NH-U12S, the NH-U12S redux still provides reliable cooling under various workloads and can handle moderate levels of overclocking.

Frost Commander 140

The Frost Commander delivers impressive performance for its size, rivaling premium cooler offerings. Capable of cooling some of the more powerful CPUs without being overly bulky, this cooler can also manage overclocking for specific CPUs. As a result, the Frost Commander is a strong contender for a wide variety of computer setups.


Noise Performance:


NH-U12S Redux

The NH-U12S redux maintains Noctua's commitment to quiet operation. The included 120mm NF-P12 redux-1700 PWM fan is designed for optimal airflow and low noise levels. Noctua fans are known for their excellent acoustic performance, and the NH-U12S redux upholds this reputation. Users can expect quiet cooling even during normal computer use.

Frost Commander 140

Featuring two differently sized fans, this cooler generates above-average noise levels relative to the cooling it provides, unlike quieter options such as the NH-D15 or the Peerless Assassin 120. If you're seeking a quieter setup, you might want to explore alternative options that better suit your needs.


Summary:


NH-U12S Redux

The Noctua NH-U12S redux is an affordable and efficient air cooler that offers good cooling capabilities and quiet operation. Its single-tower design and slim profile make it compatible with various system configurations, while its more neutral color scheme adds a modern touch. For users seeking a cost-effective cooling solution without compromising on quality, the NH-U12S redux is an excellent choice.

Frost Commander 140

The Frost Commander is a sleek, dual-tower CPU cooler with an asymmetrical design, featuring 5 heat pipes for efficient heat dissipation and a unique hidden heat pipe end design. It offers impressive performance, capable of cooling powerful CPUs and handling overclocking, making it a strong contender for various computer setups. However, with two differently sized fans, it generates above-average noise levels compared to quieter alternatives, so those seeking a quieter setup may want to consider other options.


AMD Ryzen 7 7800x3D Manufacturer's image

AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D

Pick Another CPU

CPU Details:

Metric Value
Brand AMD
Cooler Name Ryzen 7 7800X3D
CPU Socket AM5
Cores 8
Thread Count 16
Max Temperature 89°C
Base Clock 4.2GHz
Max Boost Clock 5.0GHz
Cache L1 512KB
Cache L2 8MB
Cache L3 96MB
Processor Power Base 120W
Manufacture's Link Ryzen 7 7800X3D Manufacture's Link

Product Links

Link Type Value
Amazon.com

Loading...

Copyright © 2023 · All Rights Reserved ·
Contact: derekleetechtalks@gmail.com · Privacy Policy